Study on 3D point clouds accuracy of elongated object reconstruction in close range – comparison of different software

Abstract

The image based point clouds generated from multiple different oriented photos enable 3D object reconstruction in a variety spectrum of close range applications. The paper presents the results of testing the accuracy the image based point clouds generated in disadvantageous conditions of digital photogrammetric data processing. The subject of the study was a long shaped object, i.e. the horizontal and rectilinear section of the railway track. DSLR Nikon D5100 camera, 16MP, equipped with the zoom lens (f = 18 ÷ 55mm), was used to acquire the block of terrestrial convergent and very oblique photos at different scales, with the full longitudinal overlap. The point clouds generated from digital images, automatic determination of the interior orientation parameters, the spatial orientation of photos and 3D distribution of discrete points were obtained using the successively tested software: RealityCapture, Photoscan, VisualSFM+SURE and iWitness+SURE. The dense point clouds of the test object generated with the use of RealityCapture and PhotoScan applications were filtered using MeshLab application. The geometric parameters of test object were determined by means of CloudCompare software. The image based dense point clouds allow, in the case of disadvantageous conditions of photogrammetric digital data processing, to determine the geometric parameters of a close range elongated object with the high accuracy (mXYZ < 1 mm).